Garage fixed my car then it broke down again: who helps?

Summary

If a garage charged for a repair and the same fault returned straight after collection, the claim is usually against the garage under the Consumer Rights Act 2015: the service must be performed with reasonable care and skill. You ask them to redo the work or give a price reduction. Citizens Advice (consumer service) helps you frame that complaint, check the law against your facts, or pass a report to Trading Standards. They will not write to the garage for you, chase a refund, or take the garage to court. For money recovery after a refusal, look to a trade association scheme (if the garage is a member), your card issuer where the payment tests fit, then court as a last step.

Key information

• Vehicle repair is usually a services claim, not a “faulty goods” claim against a manufacturer.
• Under the CRA you normally give the garage a chance to put the work right. You can go straight to a price reduction if a redo is impossible, would take too long, or would be very inconvenient.
• A written second opinion from another garage (or an agreed independent engineer) is often what makes “not reasonable care and skill” concrete in a dispute.
• Put the complaint in writing with dates, invoice, what failed after collection, and what you want (redo, partial refund, or full refund).
• Citizens Advice consumer advisers explain rights, talk through next steps, point you to letter templates, and can pass information to Trading Standards. They do not run the dispute for you.
• Trading Standards may investigate unfair trading. They do not get your money back for you.
• The Motor Ombudsman or another motor trade association only helps if the garage is in that scheme.
• Section 75 or chargeback only if payment tests fit. Lead with the garage complaint first.

Practical guidance

• The garage: written complaint. Ask for the repair to be redone free of charge, or for a price reduction / refund if a redo is not realistic. Attach invoice and describe the same fault after collection.
• Second opinion: another garage’s written quote or report that the original work failed. This often unlocks negotiation.
• Citizens Advice consumer service (England: 0808 223 1133): call only if you need advice on rights, how to word the ask, or a Trading Standards report. Expect advice and signposting, not casework. If you already know your ask, use their car repair page and template letter without calling.
• Trade association / Motor Ombudsman: if the garage is a member, use their conciliation route before court.
• Card issuer: Section 75 or chargeback only where payment tests fit. Keep the garage complaint file ready for the issuer.
• Ask the Shaman: free door routing if you are unsure which path fits your facts.
• Court (small claims): last resort if negotiation and any available scheme fail.

Related topics